Human Rights and Law Enforcement at Sea

Arrest, Detention and Transfer of Piracy Suspects


Law enforcement at sea has become an increasingly important tool for combating transnational crime. Such law enforcement operations are commonly directed by multinational missions composed of military rather than police forces, and are often carried out in maritime areas not subject to national jurisdiction. Because of these characteristics, maritime law enforcement operations touch upon many unresolved human rights issues. In the present study, counter-piracy operations off the coast of Somalia and in the Indian Ocean serve as the quintessential example of how law enforcement measures taken at sea may fall short of international human rights standards.

An unprecedented number of national and multinational missions have been deployed to counter the phenomenon of piracy off the coast of Somalia and in the region. Their mandate includes the arrest, detention and transfer for prosecution of piracy suspects. The book at hand examines the procedures pertinent to the decision whether to release piracy suspects, prosecute them in the seizing State or transfer them to a third State, and the detention regime pending such decisions. The study provides a critical analysis of the compatibility of these procedures with international law, first and foremost human rights law. Using piracy as an example, it demonstrates that the characteristics of national and multinational law enforcement at sea may lead to a deviation from certain human rights standards – standards that the States in question readily accept and apply in their land-based, territorial law enforcement operations. At the centre of the analysis are two unique case studies, which provide insight into the arrest, detention and transfer procedures in both a multinational context and a purely interstate setting.

This work is a valuable contribution to legal scholarship dealing with the human rights dimension of maritime law enforcement operations. It is a useful, timely and innovative resource for both academics and legal practitioners alike, or any person interested in the applicability and scope of human rights norms in the maritime context.
Open Access
Download PDF

Prices from (excl. shipping):

Dr. Anna Petrig is a post-doc researcher at the University of Basel, Switzerland. She is a member of the Management Committee of MARSAFENET (network of experts on the legal aspects of maritime safety and security; COST Action IS1105) and co-leader of its Working Group on International Maritime Security and Boarder Surveillance. Anna Petrig is a member of the Bar of the Canton of Berne, Switzerland, and the New York State Bar. She holds a PhD from the University of Basel and an LL.M. from Harvard Law School.
Awarded the Emilie Louise Frey-Preis zur Förderung junger Wissenschaftlerinnen from the University of Basel, Switzerland.

Excerpt of table of contents:
Acknowledgements; List of Abbreviations;
I. Hypothesis: Piracy Suspects Are Holders of International Individual Rights
II. Scope of the Study: Disposition in Light of International Individual Rights
III. Case Studies: Methodology Applied
Part 1 Disposition of Piracy Cases: The Context
I. The Phenomenon: Somali-Based Piracy
II. A Janus-faced Response: Internationalized Policing and Domestic Prosecution
III. Building a Bridge: Interlocking Policing and Prosecution
IV. Paving the Way for Prosecutions: Disposition of Piracy Cases
V. Conclusions on Disposition of Piracy Cases: The Context
Part 2 Disposition of Piracy Cases: The Practice
I. Disposition in an Interstate Setting: Denmark
II. Disposition in a Multinational Context: EUNAVFOR
III. Conclusions on Disposition of Piracy Cases: The Practice
Part 3 Disposition of Piracy Cases: Applicable Legal Frameworks
I. International Humanitarian Law
II. International Refugee Law
III. International Human Rights Law
Part 4 Arrest and Detention in Light of International Individual Rights
I. Arrest and Detention of Piracy Suspects in Light of the Right to Liberty
II. Procedural Safeguards for Piracy Suspects Deprived of Their Liberty
III. Conclusions on Arrest and Detention
Part 5 Transfer Decision Procedure in Light of International
Individual Rights
I. A Conditional Right Not to Be Transferred: Non-Refoulement
II. Right to an Individual Non-Refoulement Assessment
III. Right to Be a Party to Transfer Proceedings
IV. Conclusions on Transfer Decision Procedure
Concluding Remarks
I Bibliography; II United Nations Documents; III Table of Cases; IV Table of Legislation.
  • Collapse
  • Expand