Fortress Europe or Europe of Rights? The Europeanisation of Family Migration Policies in France, Germany and the Netherlands

In: European Journal of Migration and Law

Abstract

Are the restrictive reforms of family migration policy recently implemented in France, Germany and the Netherlands a result of the introduction of the Family Reunification Directive in 2003? Most existing literature on the Europeanisation of migration policies suggests that restriction-minded national governments shift decision-making to the EU level to escape domestic political and judicial constraints. However, as the Treaties of Amsterdam and Lisbon have empowered the Commission and Court to constrain restrictive reform, this perspective is losing analytical validity. Also, this perspective fails to capture the intensifying processes of policy transfer among Member States, which have inadequately been labelled ‘horizontal’ Europeanisation. We therefore propose a new, actor-centred analytical framework of Europeanisation. We show that contrasting yet parallel dynamics of Europeanisation may emanate from a single legislative instrument and may constrain and empower national governments at the same time.

  • 2)

    Bundestags-Drucksache (BT-Drs.) 16/5056 p. 171.

  • 5)

    M. Vink and P. Graziano (2007) ‘Challenges of a New Research Agenda’ in: P. Graziano and M. Vink (eds) Europeanization: New Research Agendas Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan pp. 3–20.

  • 7)

    Guiraudonsupra fn. 1 pp. 251–252.

  • 8)

    Lavenex 2001supra fn. 1 p. 863.

  • 9)

    Schainsupra fn. 1 pp. 102–106.

  • 10)

    Luedtkesupra fn. 1 p. 15.

  • 13)

    S. Bonjour and M. Vink‘When Europeanization backfires: the normalization of European migration politics’Acta Politica (forthcoming).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • 14)

    Bonjour and Vinksupra fn. 13.

  • 15)

    Vink and Grazianosupra fn. 5; C.M. Radaelli (2003) ‘The Europeanization of Public Policy’ in: K. Featherstone and C.M. Radaelli (eds) The Politics of Europeanization Oxford: Oxford University Press pp. 27–56.

  • 16)

    T. Strik (2011) Besluitvorming over asiel- en migratierichtlijnen. De wisselwerking tussen nationaal en Europees niveau. Boom Uitgevers Den Haag; Groenendijk 2006 supra fn. 4.

  • 17)

    Guiraudon; Luedtkesupra fn. 1; cf. Bonjour and Vink supra fn. 13.

  • 18)

    Groenendijk 2006supra fn. 4.

  • 19)

    Striksupra fn. 16.

  • 20)

    Striksupra fn. 16.

  • 23)

    TK 29700 (3): pp. 16–17 21 July 2004.

  • 24)

    BT-Drs. 16/5065 23 April 2007Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur Umsetzung aufenthalts- und asylrechtlicher Richtlinien der Europäischen Union.

  • 26)

    BT Pp 16/90 28 March 2007p. 9071.

  • 28)

    AN 2nd plenary session 2 May 2006.

  • 30)

    AN 1st plenary session 17 May 2006.

  • 32)

    Sénat plenary 2 October 2007.

  • 33)

    Striksupra fn. 16.

  • 35)

    Sénat plenary 15 June 2006.

  • 36)

    Sénat plenary 15 June 2006.

  • 38)

    AN Report N° 160 12 September 2007.

  • 39)

    BT Pp 16/24 p. 183815 March 2006.

  • 40)

    TK 28195 (5): 5 4 October 2002.

  • 41)

    TK plenary 16 September 2009: 2–36.

  • 42)

    TK 19637 (1266): 282 April 2009; TK 32317 (16): 15 19 May 2010.

  • 43)

    TK plenary 10 February 201053–4866; TK 32052 (22) 11 February 2010.

  • 44)

    TK 32175 (16): 32 18 January 2011.

  • 47)

    AN plenary 18 September 2007.

  • 49)

    BT Pp 16/169 p. 17863 19 June 2008.

  • 51)

    BT-Drs. 16/11997 p. 2 16 February 2009.

  • 52)

    BT Pp 16/209 p. 22640 6 March 2009.

  • 54)

    TK 29700 (54) p. 4 30 January 2008.

  • 55)

    TK 30308 (7) p. 15 23 December 2005.

  • 56)

    Striksupra fn. 16.

  • 58)

    Lavenex 2001supra fn. 1.

  • 59)

    Groenendijk 2006supra fn. 4.

  • 61)

    Groenendijk 2006supra fn. 4.

  • 62)

    Document Sj.g (2011) 5406574 May 2011.

  • 63)

    BVerwG 1 C 8.09 judgment of 30 March 2010.

  • 64)

    TK 32175 (1) 2 October 2009.

  • 65)

    TK 32417 (15): 22 7 October 2010.

  • 67)

    BT-Drs. 16/12013 18 February 2009p. 8; TK 31884 (546) 10 March 2009.

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 277 259 15
Full Text Views 279 259 7
PDF Downloads 59 56 6