A Reply to Grotius’s Critics. On Constitutional Law

in Grotiana
Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


It is not always easy to interpret Grotius’s constitutional theory that lies hidden within his book on the law of war and peace. After a very concise discussion of this constitutional framework, this study turns to various interpretations and conclusions by contemporary scholars that sit awkwardly within the theory. The interpretations of Richard Tuck, Peter Borschberg, Knud Haakonson, Frank Grunert, Deborah Baumgold, Marco Barducci, Daniel Lee and Gustaaf van Nifterik are discussed critically.

A Reply to Grotius’s Critics. On Constitutional Law

in Grotiana



Barducci M. Hugo Grotius and the Century of Revolution 1613–1718. Transnational Reception in English Political Thought. Oxford: Oxford University Press2017.

Baumgold D. Contract Theory in Historical Context. Essays on Grotius Hobbes and Locke . Leiden: Brill2010.

Borschberg P. Hugo Grotius “Commentarius in Theses xi”. An Early Treatise on Sovereignty the Just War and the Legitimacy of the Dutch Revolt. Berne: Peter Lang1994.

Borschberg P. ‘Grotius, the Social Contract and Political Resistance. A Study of the Unpublished Theses lvi’, iilj Working Paper 2006/7 . History and Theory of International Law Series.

Grotius H. Commentary on the Law of Prize and Booty ed. by Martine Julia van Ittersum. Based on the translation and edition by Gwladys L. Williams and Walter H. Zeydel. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund2006.

Grotius H. De jure belli ac pacis. Vol II the translation by Francis W. Kelsey Classics of International Law. Oxford: Clarendon Press1925.

Grotius H. Het recht van oorlog en vrede . Prologemona & Boek I. Transl. and ann. by J. F. Lindemans. Baarn: Ambo1993.

Grotius H. De iure praedae commentarius ed. by Hamaker H.G. . Hagae Comitum: Nijhoff1868.

Grunert F. Der Vertrag als rechtliches Medium sozialer Gestaltung: Zum Kontraktualismus bei Hugo Grotius’ in Konegen N. and Nitschke P. (eds.) Staat bei Hugo Grotius Staatsverständnisse 9 (Baden-Baden: Nomos2005) pp. 125137.

Grunert F. Sovereignty and Resistance: The Development of the Right of Resistance in German Natural Law’ in Natural Law and Civil Sovereignty. Moral Right and State Authority in Early Modern Political Thought ed. by Hunter Ian and Saunders David (Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan2002) pp. 123138.

Haakonssen K. Hugo Grotius and the History of Political Thought’Political Theory 13 (1985) 239265.

Lee D. Popular Sovereignty in Early Modern Constitutional Thought. Oxford University Press Scholarship Online2016.

Nifterik G. van Grotius and the Origin of the Ruler’s Right to Punish’Grotiana 26–28 (2005–2007) (also published as Hans W. Blom (ed.) Property Piracy and Punishment. Hugo Grotius on War and Booty in De Iure Praedae – Concepts and Contexts (Leiden: Brill2009) pp. 396415.

Tuck R. Natural Rights Theories . Their Origin and Development. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press1978.

Tuck R. Philosophy and Government 1572–1651. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press1993.

Tuck R. The Rights of War and Peace: Political Thought and the International Order from Grotius to Kant . Oxford: Oxford University Press1999.

Tuck R. The Sleeping Sovereign . The Invention of Modern Democracy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press2015.


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 18 18 18
Full Text Views 30 30 28
PDF Downloads 15 15 13
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0