The Selection of Situations by the ICC: An Empirically Based Evaluation of the otp’s Performance

In: International Criminal Law Review

The main aim of the International Criminal Court (icc) is to prosecute the most serious crimes of concern to the international community. One of the most valued features of the icc is the independent position of the Prosecutor in selecting situations and cases to investigate. The Prosecutor, however, has been heavily criticized for his selection policy and countries from the African Union even threatened to withdraw from the icc because of its alleged bias and unfair focus on African political leaders. In this article we present the results of our explorative study in which we empirically evaluate the situations selection policy of the icc Prosecutor. We conclude that given the icc’s limited jurisdictional reach, the Prosecutor is generally focusing on the gravest situations where international crimes are supposedly committed.

  • 21

    Kenya authorization decisionsupra note 14 para. 56.

  • 25

    De Guzmansupra note 9 p. 1432.

  • 43

    Estimate by Hawkinssupra note 37 p. 14.

  • 44

    Hawkinsibid. p. 16.

  • 56

    Hawkinssupra note 37 p. 15.

  • 72

    Hawkinssupra note 37 p. 16. See also estimates by Coghlan et al see supra note 37.

  • 84

    DeGuzmansupra note 9 p. 1461.

  • 85

    DeGuzman and Schabassupra note 5.

  • 97

    Human Security Reportsupra note 37 p. 115.

  • 128

    Kenya authorization decisionsupra note 14.

  • 130

    Forsythesupra note 81 p. 853.

  • 133

    The Human Security Report 2005supra note 37 p. 4 concluded: “At the turn of the 21st century more people were being killed in wars in this region than in the rest of the world combined.”

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 376 257 21
Full Text Views 349 104 22
PDF Downloads 117 68 17