Bilateral Labor Agreement with Gendered and Unfree Labor: Vietnamese Women Domestic Workers in Saudi Arabia
In: Journal of Labor and SocietySearch for other papers by Angie Ngọc Trần in
Current site
Google Scholar
Abstract
Using a systemic and institutional analysis of transnational dynamics in the recruiting, hiring and placement of Vietnamese female migrants in domestic work in Saudi Arabia, this article showcases the experiences of Vietnamese female domestic workers in Saudi Arabia and contributes to the social protection and migrant domestic worker literatures. It contributes a critical analysis on whether bilateral labor agreements can be mechanisms for social protection of migrants. Focusing on the case of Vietnam, I argue that the bilateral labor agreement (bla) signed between Vietnam and Saudi Arabia, enacted by the Vietnamese labor brokerage state and the Saudi Kafala systems, is a form structural violence because it fails to provide social welfare and protection for Vietnamese women domestic workers. In this systemic/structural violence, intersectionality shows that not all female workers suffer the same since ethnic minority workers most often suffer more than the majority (Kinh) female workers. Moreover, inside the Kafeel (the employer/sponsor) homes of this system, most of these female workers suffer, as unfree labor, from being transferred from one house to another, resulting in precarity, cycle of debt and dispossession of their rights.
Purchase
Buy instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):
Institutional Login
Log in with Open Athens, Shibboleth, or your institutional credentials
Personal login
Log in with your brill.com account
-
Al Jazeera. “Saudi Arabia announces changes to Kafala system.” Al Jazeera online (14 March 2021), available online at https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/3/14/saudi-arabias-long-awaited-kafala-reform-goes-into-effect.
-
Alzahrani, M.M. “The System of Kafala and the Rights of Migrant Workers in gcc Countries – with Specific Reference to Saudi Arabia.” European Journal of Law Reform 16 (2) (2014), 377–400.
-
Bélanger, D., L.B. Dương, T.G. Linh, and K.T. Hồng. International Labor Migration from Vietnam to Asian countries: Process, Experiences, and Impact (Hanoi: Institute for Social Development Studies, 2010).
-
Bélanger, D., K. Ueno, K.T. Hồng and E. Ochiai. “From Foreign Trainees to Unauthorized Workers: Vietnamese Migrant Workers in Japan.” Asian and Pacific Migration Journal 20 (1) (2011), 31–53.
-
Bình, T. “Công ty Vĩnh Cát: Có “mang con bỏ chợ”? Thương Hiệu & Công Luận (24 January 2018), available online at https://thuonghieucongluan.com.vn/cong-ty-vinh-cat-co-mang-con-bo-cho-a46468.html.
-
Brass, T. “Some Observations on Unfree Labour, Capitalist Restructuring, and Deproletarianization.” International Review of Social History 39 (1994), 255–275. doi: 10.1017/S0020859000112593.
-
Brass, T. “Unfree Labour as Primitive Accumulation?” Capital & Class 35 (1) (2011), 23–38. doi: 10.1177/0309816810392969.
-
Breman, J., K. Harris, C.K. Lee and M. van der Linden, eds. The Social Question in the Twenty-First Century: A Global View (Oakland, CA: University of California Press, 2019). doi: 10.1525/luminos.74.
-
Chin, C.B.N. In Service and Servitude: Foreign Female Domestic Workers and the Malaysian “Modernity” Project (New York, NY: Columbia University Press, 1998).
-
Crinis, V. “Vietnamese Migrant Clothing Workers in Malaysia: Global Production: Transnational Labour Migration and Social Reproduction.” In The Global Political Economy of the Household in Asia, eds. J. Elias and S.J. Gunawardana (Berlin: Springer, 2013), 162–177.
-
Crinis, V. and A.N. Trần, “Migrant Workers in the Clothing Industry: Networking in Christian Spaces.” in Labour in the Clothing Industry in the Asia Pacific, eds. V. Crinis and A. Vickers (London: Routledge, 2017), 80–96.
-
de Haas, H. “Migration and Development: A Theoretical Perspective.” The International Migration Review 44 (1) (2010), 227–264. doi: 10.1111/j.1747-7379.2009.00804.x.
-
DoLAB. List of Export Enterprises (2022), available online at http://dolab.gov.vn/BU/Index.aspx?LIST_ID=1371&type=hdmbmtmn&MENU_ID=246&DOC_ID=1561.
-
Dương, Y. “Overworked, abused, hungry: Vietnamese domestic workers in Saudi.” Al Jazeera (19 September 2018), available online at https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2018/9/19/overworked-abused-hungry-vietnamese-domestic-workers-in-saudi.
-
Embassy of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Danh Sách Các Công Ty Xuất Khẩu Lao Động Được Phép Đóng Visa Cho Lao Động Đi Ả Rập, March 18, 2018. (List of Labor Export Companies Allowed to Stamp Visas for Workers Going to Saudi Arabia, March 18, 2018.).
-
Ewers, M.C., A. Diop, K.T. Le and L. Bader, “Migrant Worker Well‑Being and Its Determinants: The Case of Qatar.” Social Indicators Research 152 (2020), 137–163.
-
Farmer, P., B. Nizeye, S. Stulac and S. Keshavjee, “Structural Violence and Clinical Medicine.” PLoS Medicine, Policy Forum 3 (10) (2006), e449.
-
Galtung, J. “Violence, Peace, and Peace Research.” Journal of Peace Research 6 (3) (1969), 167–191.
-
Glo-Tech. “Glo-Tech, Vietnam and Saudi Arabia signed Agreement of Manpower Cooperation.” Glo-Tech (2014a), available online at https://glotech.vn/vietnam-and-saudi-arabia-signed-agreement-of-manpower-cooperation/.
-
Glo-Tech. “The visit of the Delegation of Ministry of Labour of Saudi Arabia to Glo-Tech’s Training Center.” Glo-Tech (2014b), available online at https://glotech.vn/the-visit-of-the-delegation-of-ministry-of-labour-of-saudi-arabia-to-glo-techs-training-center/.
-
Guevarra, A.R. Marketing Dreams, Manufacturing Heroes: The Transnational Labor Brokering of Filipino Workers (New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 2009).
-
Hennebry, J.L., N. Piper, H. KC and K. Williams. “Bilateral Labor Agreements As Migration Governance Tools: An Analysis From A Gender Lens.” Theoretical Inquiries in Law 23 (2) (2022), 184–204.
-
Hoàng, L.A. and B.S.A. Yeoh. “Transnational Labour Migration, Debts and Family Economics in Vietnam.” In Transnational Labour Migration, Remittances and the Changing Family in Asia. Anthropology, Change and Development Series (London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2015), 283–310.
-
Hujo, K. and N. Piper. “Bridging gaps in research and policy: towards inclusive migration and social policy regimes.” In South-South Migration: Implications for Social Policy and Development (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2010), 220–229.
-
Human Rights Watch, “Saudi Arabia: Labor Reforms Insufficient; Abusive Elements Remain; Changes Exclude Domestic Workers.” Human Rights Watch (25 March 2021), available online at https://www.hrw.org/news/2021/03/25/saudi-arabia-labor-reforms-insufficient.
-
Levitt, P, J. Viterna, A. Mueller and C. Lloyd. “Transnational Social Protection: Setting the Agenda.” Oxford Development Studies 45 (1) (2017), 2–19. doi: 10.1080/13600818.2016.1239702.
-
Lin, J. and M.T. Nguyễn. “The cycle of commodification: migrant labour, welfare, and the market in global China and Vietnam.” Global Public Policy and Governance 1 (3) (2021), 321–339.
-
Lin, J., D. Arnold and M.T. Nguyễn. “Welfare in Crisis: Labor and Social Protection in the Global South.” Journal of Labor and Society, in press.
-
Lindquist, J. “Labor Recruitment, Circuits of Capital and Gendered Mobility: Reconceptualizing the Indonesian Migration Industry.” Pacific Affairs 83 (1) (2010): 115–132.
-
Mahdavi, P. “Gender, labour and the law: the nexus of domestic work, human trafficking and the informal economy in the United Arab Emirates.” Global Networks 13 (4) (2013) 425–440.
-
MoLISA. “Quy định chức năng, nhiệm vụ, quyền hạn và cơ cấu tổ chức của Cục quản lý lao động ngoài nước.” [Defining the functions, tasks, authorities and organizational structure of the Department of Overseas Labor]. MoLISA (2017), available online at http://english.molisa.gov.vn/Pages/About/OrganizationalDetail.aspx?ToChucID=2230.
-
Murray, H.E. “Hope for Reform Springs Eternal: How the Sponsorship System, Domestic Laws and Traditional Customs Fail to Protect Migrant Domestic Workers in gcc Countries.” Cornell International Law Journal 45 (2) (2012), 461–485.
-
Nguyễn, Q.P. and S. Venkatesh. “Does migration make financial sense? The case of domestic workers from Vietnam to Taiwan.” International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 35 (11–12) (2015), 722–737. doi: 10.1108/IJSSP-10-2014-0080.
-
Pande, A. “’The Paper that You Have in Your Hand is My Freedom’: Migrant Domestic Work and the Sponsorship (Kafala) System in Lebanon.” The International Migration Review 47 (2) (2013), 414–441.
-
Piper, N. “Feminisation of Labour Migration as an Issue of Violence – International, Regional and Local ngo Responses in Asia.” Violence Against Women, 9 (6) (2003), 723–745.
-
Piper, N. “Democratising Migration from the Bottom Up: The Rise of the Global Migrant Rights Movement.” Globalizations 12 (5) (2015), 788–802. doi: 10.1080/14747731.2015.1024454.
-
Rahman, M.M. “Migrant indebtedness: Bangladeshis in the gcc countries.” International Migration 53 (6) (2015), 205–219.
-
Rodriguez, R.M. Migrants for Export: How the Philippine State Brokers Labor to the World (Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 2010).
-
Rodriguez, R.M. and A.R. Guevarra. Manufacturing Heroes: The Transnational Labor Brokering of Filipino Workers (New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 2009).
-
Rosewarne, S. “Globalisation and the commodification of labour: Temporary labour migration.” The Economic and Labour Relations Review 20 (2) (2010), 99–110.
-
Sadiq, K. and G. Tsourapas. “The Postcolonial Migration State.” European Journal of International Relations 27 (3) (2021), 884–912. doi: 10.1177/13540661211000114.
-
Trần, A.N. “Modern-day slavery: Vietnamese women domestic workers in Saudi Arabia.” New Mandala (29 November 2021), available online at https://www.newmandala.org/modern-day-slavery-vietnamese-women-domestic-workers-in-saudi-arabia/.
-
Trần, A.N. Ethnic Dissent and Empowerment: Economic Migration between Vietnam and Malaysia (Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press, 2022a).
-
Trần, A.N. “The Kafala system and Vietnam’s domestic workers: Corruption and a Silenced Press.” New Mandala (12 Feb 2022), available online at https://www.newmandala.org/the-kafala-system-and-vietnams-domestic-workers-corruption-and-a-silenced-press/.
-
Trần, A.N. “Contradictions of Multi-stakeholder Labor Relations in Vietnam,” in Routledge Handbook of Contemporary Vietnam, ed. J.D. London (Abingdon: Routledge, 2022b), chapter 14.
-
Trần, A.N. and V. Crinis. “Migrant Labor and State Power: Vietnamese Workers in Malaysia and Vietnam.” Journal of Vietnamese Studies 13 (2) (2018), 27–73.
-
Tsogas, G. “Transnational Labor Regulation – Where to Next?” Journal of Labor and Society 23 (2) (2020), 143–179. doi: 10.1111/LANDS.12474.
-
US Department of State, Trafficking in Persons Report (Washington, DC: US Department of State, 2022), available online at https://www.state.gov/reports/2022-trafficking-in-persons-report/592-596.
-
vamas. “Quyết Định Thành lập và Bổ Nhiệm Lãnh Đạo Ban Thị Trường Giúp Việc Gia Đình Trung Đông.” (Establishment and Appointment of Leaders of the Department for Marketing Domestic Workers in Middle East Families). VAMAS (17 December 2020), available online at http://www.vamas.com.vn/quyet-dinh-bo-nhiem-lanh-dao-ban_t221c695n44537, 28/qđ-hhxklđ.
-
Vân, H. and H. Nam, “Labor Export.” vov World (2015), available online at https://vovworld.vn/en-US/current-affairs/labor-export-opportunities-in-2015-314083.vov.
-
voa. “17-year-old Vietnamese girl dies after two years of labour in Saudi Arabia.” voa (3 October 2021), available online at https://www.voatiengviet.com/a/thieu-nu-nguoi-viet-17-tuoi-chet-sau-hai-nam-lao-dong-o-a-rap-xe-ut/6254569.html.
-
Wang, H. and Bélanger, D. (2011), “The recruitment process of migrant workers in Asia: from Vietnam to Taiwan.” In Vietnam Update: Labour in Vietnam, ed. C. Anita (Canberra, ACT: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 2011), 309–334.
-
Xiang, B. and J. Lindquist. “Migration Infrastructure.” International Migration Review 48 (S1) (2014), S122–S148. doi: 10.1111/imre.12141.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 840 | 667 | 31 |
| Full Text Views | 84 | 50 | 16 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 260 | 187 | 9 |
Bilateral Labor Agreement with Gendered and Unfree Labor: Vietnamese Women Domestic Workers in Saudi Arabia
In: Journal of Labor and SocietySearch for other papers by Angie Ngọc Trần in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Abstract
Using a systemic and institutional analysis of transnational dynamics in the recruiting, hiring and placement of Vietnamese female migrants in domestic work in Saudi Arabia, this article showcases the experiences of Vietnamese female domestic workers in Saudi Arabia and contributes to the social protection and migrant domestic worker literatures. It contributes a critical analysis on whether bilateral labor agreements can be mechanisms for social protection of migrants. Focusing on the case of Vietnam, I argue that the bilateral labor agreement (bla) signed between Vietnam and Saudi Arabia, enacted by the Vietnamese labor brokerage state and the Saudi Kafala systems, is a form structural violence because it fails to provide social welfare and protection for Vietnamese women domestic workers. In this systemic/structural violence, intersectionality shows that not all female workers suffer the same since ethnic minority workers most often suffer more than the majority (Kinh) female workers. Moreover, inside the Kafeel (the employer/sponsor) homes of this system, most of these female workers suffer, as unfree labor, from being transferred from one house to another, resulting in precarity, cycle of debt and dispossession of their rights.
| All Time | Past 365 days | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 840 | 667 | 31 |
| Full Text Views | 84 | 50 | 16 |
| PDF Views & Downloads | 260 | 187 | 9 |