Unity of the Persianate World under Turko-Mongolian Domination and Divergent Development of Imperial Autocracies in the Sixteenth Century

In: Journal of Persianate Studies

The promotion of the Persianate normative model of imperial kingship was the major ecumenical contribution of the Persian bureaucrats who served the Saljuq and Mongol rulers of Iran and Anatolia in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries to state-building. The phenomenal growth of popular Sufism in Timurid Iran and early Ottoman Anatolia had a highly paradoxical impact on the legitimacy of kingship, making its conception increasingly autocratic. Both in the Ottoman and the Safavid successor empires, the disintegrative tendency of nomadic patrimonial empires was countered by variants of Persianate imperial monarchy. It is argued that the decisive event in sundering the ecumenical unity of the Persianate world was not the conquest of Constantinople in 1453, but the Mahdist revolution of the Safavid sheykhoghlu, Shah Esmāʿil, half a century later. The parting of ways stemmed from the variant of mystically enhanced autocracy adopted in the two cases—one with orthodox, Sunni, and the other with heterodox, Shiʿite inflection. The latter model became the Safavid model of autocracy under Shah Esmāʿil, and was quickly adopted by the Timurids after their conquest of India in 1526.

  • Afshar I. “Pandnāma-ye Māturidi” Farhang-e Irān-Zamin 1961/1340 9 46 66

  • Āqsarāʾi Mahmud b. Mohammad O. Turan Ankara Müsâmeret ül-Ahbâr 1944

  • Arjomand S. A. The Shadow of God and the Hidden Imam: Religion, Political Organization and Societal Change in Shiʿite Iran from the Beginning to 1890 1984 Chicago

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Arjomand S. A. Arnason J. & Wittrock B. “Transformation of the Islamicate Civilization: A Turning Point in the Thirteenth Century?” Eurasian Transformations, 10th to 13th Centuries: Crystallizations, Divergences, Renaissances 2004 Leiden 213 245

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Arjomand S. A. “Rise of Shāh Esmāʿil as a Mahdist Revolution” Studies on Persianate Societies 2005 3 44 65

  • Arjomand S. A. Irwin R. “Legitimacy and Political Organisation: Caliphs, Kings and Regimes” The New Cambridge History of Islam 2010 vol. 4 Cambridge 225 273

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Arjomand S. A. “State Formation in Early Modern Muslim Empires: Common Origin and Divergent Paths” Social Imaginaries 2016 1 4

  • Babinger F. “Schejch Bedred-din, der Sohn des Richters von Simaw” Der Islam 1921 11 1 100

  • Bedlisi Edris Qānun-e shānshāhi 1974 see Tavakkoli

  • Binbaş İ. E. Mir-Kasimov O. “Timurid Experimentation with Eschatological Absolutism: Mirza Iskandar, Shah Niʿmatullah Wali, and Sayyid Sharif Jurjani in 815/1412” Unity in Diversity. Mysticism, Messianism and the Construction of Religious Authority in Islam 2014 Leiden 277 303

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Chittick W. C. Divine Love. Islamic Literature and the Path to God 2014 New Haven

  • Darling L. “Contested Territory: Ottoman Holy War in Comparative Context” Studia Islamica 2000 91 133 163

  • Darling L. “Persianate Sources in Anatolia and the Early History of the Ottomans Studies on Persianate Societies 2004 2 126 144

  • Dehkhoda A. A. Loghat-nāma-ye Dehkhodā 1998/1377 Tehran 15 vols.

  • Durand-Guédy D. Mitchell L. & Melville Ch. “Ruling from the Outside: A New Perspective on Early Turkish Kingship in Iran” Every Inch a King. Comparative Studies on Kings and Kingship in the Ancient and Medieval Worlds 2013 Leiden 325 342

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Ebn Bibi Amir Nāser al-Din Hosayn Mashkur M. J. Akhbār-e Salājeqa-ye Rum 1971/1350 Tehran

  • Fleet K. Fierro M. “The Rise of the Ottomans” The New Cambridge History of Islam 2010 vol. 2 Cambridge 313 331

  • Fleischer C. H. “Mawlānā Hakim al-Dīn Bedlisi” Encylopaedia Iranica 1989 vol. 4 75 76

  • Fleischer C. H. “Messiah as Lawgiver: The Making of the Imperial Image in the reign of Süleymân” Soliman le magnifique et son temps 1992 Paris 159 177

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Fletcher J. “Turko-Mongolian Monarchic Tradition in the Ottoman Empire” Harvard Ukrainian Studies 1979-1980 3-4 1 236 251

  • Fouchécour Ch.-H. de Moralia. les notions morales dans la literature persane du 3e/9e au 7e/13e siècle 1986 Paris

  • Ebn Battuta Defrémery Ch. F. & Sanguinetti B. R. Voyages d’Ibn Batoutah 1990 vol. 2 Paris

  • Hakim-e Samarqandi Abuʾl-Qāsem Esḥāq b. Moḥammad Tarjoma-ye al-sawād al-aʿzam 1969/1348 Tehran

  • İnalcık H. Lewis B. & Holt P. M. “The Rise of Ottoman Historiography” Historians of the Middle East 1962 London 152 167

  • Karamustafa A. T. God’s Unruly Friends. Dervish Groups in the Islamic Middle Period 1200-1550 2006 Oxford

  • Karamustafa A. T. Mir-Kasimov O. “Kaygusuz Abdal: a Medieval Turkish Saint and the Formation of Vernacular Islam in Anatolia” Unity in Diversity. Mysticism, Messianism and the Construction of Religious Authority in Islam 2014 Leiden 329 342

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Köprülü M. F. Les origines de l’empire ottoman 1935 Paris

  • Köprülü M. F. Leiser G. The Seljuks of Anatolia: Their History and Culture According to Local Muslim Sources 1992 Salt Lake City

  • Lane G. Early Mongol Rule in Thirteenth Century Iran: A Persian Renaissance 2003 London and New York

  • Manz B. F. “The Ulus Chaghatay before and after Temür’s Rise to Power: The Transformation from Tribal Confederation to Army of Conquest” Central Asiatic Journal 1983 27 1-2 79 100

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Meisami J. S. Persian Historiography to the End of the Twelfth Century 1999 Edinburgh

  • Melville Ch. Mitchell L. & Melville Ch. “The Royal Image in Mongol Iran” Every Inch a King: Comparative Studies on Kings and Kingship in the Ancient and Medieval Worlds 2013 Leiden 343 369

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Moin A. A. The Millennial Sovereign: Sacred Kingship and Sainthood in Islam 2012 New York City

  • Peirce L. P. The Imperial Harem. Women and Sovereignty in the Ottoman Empire 1993 Oxford

  • Rāzi Najm al-Din Abu Bakr b. Mohammad Riyāhi M. A. Mersād al-ʿebād 1973/1352 Tehran tr. H. Algar as The Path of God’s Bondsmen from Origin to Return, English translation by Hamid Algar, New York, 1982

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Richards J. F. Alam M. & Subrahmanyam S. “The Formulation of Imperial Authority under Akbar and Jahangir” The Mughal State, 1526-1750 1998 Delhi 126 167

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Saʿdi Shirāzi Sheykh Moslem al-Din Nafisi Saʿid Golestān 1966/1345 Tehran

  • Safari-Aqqalʿa ʿAli Saket M. H. “Tafsir-e bozorg o nokāti dar bāra-ye dibācha-ye ān” Tabari-pazhuhi 2014/1393 vol. 1 Tehran 347 367

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Sawyer C. Bridges M. & Bürgel J. Ch. “Sword of Conquest, Dove of the Soul: Political and Spiritual Values in Ahmadi’s Iskandarnāma” The Problematics of Powers: Eastern and Western Representations of Alexander the Great 1996 Bern and New York 135 148

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Taeschner F. “Ak̲h̲ī,” “Ak̲h̲ī Bābā,” “Ak̲h̲ī Ewrān” and “Ankara” Encyclopedia of Islam 1960 vol. 1 321 325 509 511

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Jalali N. Tārikh-e āl-e Saljuq dar Ānātuli 1999/1377 Tehran

  • Tavvakoli H. “İdris Biltlisi’nin ‘Kanun-ı sahenşahisi’nin’ tenkidli neşri ve türkçeye tercümesi” 1974 unpub. Ph.D. diss., University of Istanbul

    • Export Citation
  • Tripathi R. P. Alam M. & Subrahmanyam S. “The Turko-Mongol Theory of Kingship” The Mughal State, 1526-1750 1998 Delhi 114 125

  • Yazdi Sharaf al-Din ʿAli Afshar I. Monshaʾāt 2009/1388 Tehran

  • Yıldırım R. “Turkomans between Two Empires: The Origins of the Qizilbash Identity in Anatolia (1447-1514)” 2008 unpub. Ph.D. diss., Bilkent University

    • Export Citation
  • Zarrinkub ʿA.-H. Jostoju dar tasavvof-e Irān 1984/1363 Tehran 2 vols.

  • 3

    See further, Meisami 1999, 18-20.

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 113 69 6
Full Text Views 221 32 5
PDF Downloads 21 12 0