Avicenna against Mathematical Platonism

In: Oriens
View More View Less
  • 1 Clare Hall, University of Cambridge

Purchase instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):



In this paper I investigate Avicenna’s criticisms of the separateness of mathematical objects and of the view that they are principles for natural things. These two theses form the core of Plato’s view of mathematics; i.e., mathematical Platonism. Surprisingly, Avicenna does not consider his arguments against these theses as attacks on Plato. This is because his understanding of Plato’s philosophy of mathematics differs from both Plato’s original view and what Aristotle attributes to Plato.

  • Adam, James. The Republic of Plato. 2nd edition. 2 vols. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1963.

  • Adamson, Peter. “The Kindian Tradition: The Structure of Philosophy in Arabic Neoplatonism.” In Libraries of the Neoplatonists. Ed. by Cristina D’Ancona. Leiden: Brill, 2007, 351–70.

  • Adamson, Peter, and Fedor Benevich. “The Thought Experimental Method: Avicenna’s Flying Man Argument.” Journal of the American Philosophical Association 4.2 (2018): 147–64.

  • Alexander of Aphrodisias. In Aristotelis metaphysica commentaria [Greek]. Ed. by Michael Hayduck. Berlin: Georg Reimer, 1891.

  • Alwishah, Ahmed. “Ibn Sīnā on Floating Man Arguments.” Journal of Islamic Philosophy 9 (2013): 49–71.

  • Annas, Julia. “On the ‘Intermediates.’ ” Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie 57.2 (1975): 146–66.

  • Aristotle. The Complete Works of Aristotle: The Revised Oxford Translation. Ed. by Jonathan Barnes. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1984.

  • Arsen, Hera S. “A Case for the Utility of the Mathematical Intermediates.” Philosophia Mathematica 20.2 (2012): 200–23.

  • Avicenna. The Metaphysics of The Healing. Ed. and transl. by Michael E. Marmura. Provo: Brigham Young University Press, 2005.

  • Bahlul, Raja. “Avicenna and the Problem of Universals.” Philosophy and Theology 21.1–2 (2009): 3–25.

  • Benacerraf, Paul. “Mathematical Truth.” The Journal of Philosophy 70.19 (1973): 661–79.

  • Bertolacci, Amos. The Reception of Aristotle’s Metaphysics in Avicenna’s Kitāb al-Šifāʾ. Leiden: Brill, 2006.

  • Black, Deborah L. “Estimation (Wahm) in Avicenna: The Logical and Psychological Dimensions.” Dialogue 32.2 (1993): 219–58.

  • Bostock, David. Philosophy of Mathematics: An Introduction. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, 2009.

  • Bostock, David. “Aristotle’s Philosophy of Mathematics.” In The Oxford Handbook of Aristotle. Ed. by Christopher Shields. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012, 465–92.

  • Burnyeat, Myles F. “Platonism and Mathematics: A Prelude to Discussion.” In Mathematics and Metaphysics in Aristotle. Ed. by A. Graeser. Bern: Paul Haupt, 1987, 213–40.

  • Burnyeat, Myles F. and Michael Fred. The Seventh Platonic Letter: A Seminar. Ed. by Dominic Scott. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015.

  • Cherniss, Harold F. The Riddle of the Early Academy. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1945.

  • Cleary, John J. “Emending Aristotle’s Division of Theoretical Sciences.” The Review of Metaphysics 48.1 (1994): 33–70.

  • Corkum, Phil. “Aristotle on Mathematical Truth.” British Journal for the History of Philosophy 20.6 (2012): 1057–76.

  • Dancy, Russell. “Speusippus.” In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Winter 2016 Edition. Ed. by Edward N. Zalta. URL = https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2016/entries/speusippus/.

  • Dillon, John M. The Middle Platonists: 80 B.C. to A.D. 220. Revised edition. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1996.

  • Eslick, Leonard J. “Aristotle and the Identity of Indiscernibles.” The Modern Schoolman 36.4 (1959): 279–87.

  • Eslick, Leonard J. “The Two Cratyluses: The Problem of Identity of Indiscernibles.” Atti Del XII Congresso Internazionale Di Filosofia 11 (1960): 81–87.

  • Euclid. The Thirteen Books of Euclid’s Elements. Transl. by Thomas Little Heath. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1908.

  • al-Fārābi. Alfārābī’s philosophische Abhandlungen. Ed. by Friedrich Dieterici. Leiden: E.J. Brill, 1890.

  • Franklin, Lee. “Inventing Intermediates: Mathematical Discourse and Its Objects in RepublicVII.” Journal of the History of Philosophy 50.4 (2012): 483–506.

  • Garner, John V. “Thinking Beyond Identity: Numbers and the Identity of Indiscernibles in Plato and Proclus.” Idealistic Studies 47.1–2 (2017): 99–122.

  • Gutas, Dimitri. “Medical Theory and Scientific Method in the Age of Avicenna.” In Before and After Avicenna: Proceedings of the First Conference of the Avicenna Study Group. Ed. by David C. Reisman and Ahmed H. al-Rahim. Leiden: Brill, 2003, 145–62.

  • Gutas, Dimitri. “The Empiricism of Avicenna.” Oriens 40.2 (2012): 391–436.

  • Gutas, Dimitri. Avicenna and the Aristotelian Tradition. 2nd edition. Leiden: Brill, 2014.

  • Hall, Robert E. “The Wahm in Ibn Sina’s Psychology.” In Intellect and Imagination in Medieval Philosophy. Ed. by Maria Cândida Pacheco and José F. Meirinhos. Turnhout: Brepols, 2006, 1:533–49.

  • Hodges, Wilfrid. “Affirmative and Negative in Ibn Sīnā.” In Insolubles and Consequences: Essays in Honour of Stephen Read. Ed. by Catarina Dutilh Novaes and Ole Thomassen Hjortland. London: College Publications, 2012, 119–34.

  • Hussey, Edward. “Aristotle on Mathematical Objects.” Apeiron 24.4 (1991): 105–33.

  • Hyman, Arthur. “Aristotle’s ‘First Matter’ and Avicenna’s and Averroes’ ‘Corporeal Form.’ ” In Essays in Medieval Jewish and Islamic Philosophy. Ed. by Arthur Hyman. New York: KTAV Publishing House, 1977, 335–56.

  • Ibn Sīnā. Dānešnāma-ye ʿAlāʾī, Ilāhīyāt. Ed. by Moḥammad Moʿīn. Tehran: Anǧoman-e āṯār-e mellī, 1952.

  • Ibn Sīnā. al-Šifāʾ, al-Manṭiq, al-Madḫal. Ed. by Georges C. Anawāti, Maḥmūd al-Ḫuḍayrī and Aḥmad Fuʾād al-Ahwānī. Cairo: al-Maṭbaʿa al-amīrīya, 1952.

  • Ibn Sīnā. al-Šifāʾ, al-Manṭiq, al-Burhān. Ed. by Abū l-ʿAlā ʿAfīfī. Cairo: al-Maṭbaʿa al-amīrīya, 1956.

  • Ibn Sīnā. al-Šifāʾ, al-Manṭiq, al-Safsaṭa. Ed. by Aḥmad Fuʾād al-Ahwānī. Cairo: al-Maṭbaʿa al-amīrīya, 1958.

  • Ibn Sīnā. al-Šifāʾ, al-Manṭiq, al-ʿIbāra. Ed. by Ibrāhīm Madkūr. Cairo: Dār al-kātib al-ʿarabī li-l-ṭabāʿa wa-l-našr, 1970.

  • Ibn Sīnā. al-Išārāt wa-l-tanbīhāt bi-Šarḥ al-Ṭūsī, al-Manṭiq [= Remarks and Admonitions: With Commentary by Tusi]. Ed. by Sulaymān Dunyā. 3rd edition. Cairo: Dār al-maʿārif, 1983.

  • Ibn Sīnā. al-Naǧāt. Ed. by Muhammad Taqī Danišpažūh. Tehran: Entešārāt-e Dānešgāh-e Tehrān, 1985.

  • Kahn, Charles H. Pythagoras and the Pythagoreans: A Brief History. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company, 2001.

  • Kaukua, Jari. “Avicenna on Negative Judgement.” Topoi (forthcoming).

  • Kukkonen, Taneli. “Ibn Sīnā and the Early History of Thought Experiments.” Journal of the History of Philosophy 52.3 (2014): 433–59.

  • Lear, Jonathan. “Aristotle’s Philosophy of Mathematics.” Philosophical Review 91.2 (1982): 161–92.

  • Lizzini, Olga. “The Relation Between Form and Matter: Some Brief Observations on the ‘Homology Argument’ (Ilāhīyāt, II.4) and the Deduction of Fluxus.” In Interpreting Avicenna—Science and Philosophy in Medieval Islam: Proceedings of the Second Conference of the Avicenna Study Group. Ed. by Jon McGinnis and David C. Reisman. Leiden: Brill, 2004, 175–85.

  • Marmura, Michael E. “Avicenna and the Problem of the Infinite Number of Souls.” Mediaeval Studies 22 (1960): 232–39.

  • Marmura, Michael E. “Avicenna’s Chapter on Universals in the Isagoge of His Shifāʾ.” In Islam: Past Influence and Present Challenge. Ed. by Alford T. Welch and Pierre Cachia. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 1979, 34–56.

  • Marmura, Michael E. “Avicenna on the Division of Sciences in the Isagoge of His Shifāʾ.” Journal for the History of Arabic Science 4.2 (1980): 239–51.

  • Marmura, Michael E. “Avicenna’s ‘Flying Man’ in Context.” The Monist 69.3 (1986): 383–95.

  • Marmura, Michael E. “Quiddity and Universality in Avicenna.” In Neoplatonism and Islamic Thought. Ed. by Parviz Morewedge. New York: State University of New York Press, 1992, 77–88.

  • Marmura, Michael E. “Avicenna’s Critique of Platonists in Book VII, Chapter 2 of the Metaphysics of His Healing.” In Arabic Theology, Arabic Philosophy: From the Many to the One; Essays in Celebration of Richard M. Frank. Ed. by James Montgomery. Louvain: Peeters Publishers, 2006, 355–69.

  • McGinnis, Jon. “Avicennan Infinity: A Select History of the Infinite through Avicenna.” Documenti E Studi Sulla Tradizione Filosofica Medieval 21 (2010): 199–221.

  • McGinnis, Jon. “Experimental Thoughts on Thought Experiments in Medieval Islam.” In The Routledge Companion to Thought Experiments. Ed. by M.T. Stuart, Y. Fehige, & J.R. Brown. London: Routledge, 2017, 77–91.

  • Merlan, Philip. From Platonism to Neoplatonism. 3rd edition. Dordrecht: Springer, 1975.

  • Moravcsik, Julius. “Plato on Numbers and Mathematics.” In Ancient and Medieval Traditions in the Exact Sciences: Essays in Memory of Wilbur Knorr. Ed. by Patrick Suppes, Julius M. Moravcsik and Henry Mendell. Stanford: CSLI Publications, 2000, 177–96.

  • Mueller, Ian. “On Some Academic Theories of Mathematical Objects.” The Journal of Hellenic Studies 106 (1986): 111–20.

  • Panza, Marco, and Andrea Sereni. Plato’s Problem: An Introduction to Mathematical Platonism. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2013.

  • Plato. Plato: Complete Works. Ed. by John M. Cooper. Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company, 1997.

  • Porro, Pasquale. “Immateriality and Separation in Avicenna and Thomas Aquinas.” In The Arabic, Hebrew and Latin Reception of Avicenna’s Metaphysics. Ed. by Dag Nikolaus Hasse and Amos Bertolacci. Berlin: De Gruyter, 2011, 275–307.

  • Pritchard, Paul. Plato’s Philosophy of Mathematics. Sankt Augustin: Academic Verlag, 1995.

  • Proclus. A Commentary on the First Book of Euclid’s Elements. Transl. by Glenn R. Morrow. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1970.

  • Richardson, Kara. “Avicenna and Aquinas on Form and Generation.” In The Arabic, Hebrew and Latin Reception of Avicenna’s Metaphysics. Ed. by Nikolaus Dag Hasse and Amos Bertolacci. Berlin: De Gruyter, 2012, 251–74.

  • Riedweg, Christoph. Pythagoras: His Life, Teaching, and Influence. Transl. by Steven Rendall. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2005.

  • Shapiro, Stewart. Thinking about Mathematics: The Philosophy of Mathematics. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000.

  • Shihadeh, Ayman. “Avicenna’s Corporeal Form and Proof of Prime Matter in Twelfth-Century Critical Philosophy: Abū l-Barakāt, al-Masʿūdī and al-Rāzī.” Oriens 42.3–4 (2014.): 364–96.

  • Thom, Paul. “Al-Fārābī on Indefinite and Privative Names.” Arabic Sciences and Philosophy 18.2 (2008): 193–209.

  • Uluç, Tahir. “Al-Suhrawardī’s Critique of Ibn Sīnā’s Refutation of the Platonic Forms.” Ilahiyat Studies 3.1 (2012): 7–27.

  • Wedberg, Andres. Plato’s Philosophy of Mathematics. Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell, 1955.

  • Wilson, J. Cook. “On the Platonist Doctrine of the ἀσύμβλητοι ἀριθμοί.” The Classical Review 18.5 (1904): 247–60.

  • Yang, Moon-Heum. “The Relationship between Hypotheses and Images in the Mathematical Subsection of the Divided Line of Plato’s Republic.” Dialogue 44.2 (2005): 285–312.

  • Zarepour, Mohammad Saleh. “Avicenna on the Nature of Mathematical Objects.” Dialogue 55.3 (2016): 511–36.

  • Zarepour, Mohammad Saleh. “Avicenna on Mathematical Infinity.” Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie (forthcoming).

  • Zhmud, Leonid Ja. “ ‘All Is Number’? ‘Basic Doctrine’ of Pythagoreanism Reconsidered.” Phronesis 34.3 (1989): 270–92.

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 405 268 18
Full Text Views 57 14 0
PDF Views & Downloads 56 26 1