Demonstration and the Indemonstrability of the Stoic Indemonstrables

In: Phronesis
View More View Less
  • 1 All Souls College, Oxford University

Purchase instant access (PDF download and unlimited online access):

€25.00$30.00

Abstract

Since Mates’ seminal Stoic Logic there has been uncertainty and debate about how to treat the term anapodeiktos when used of Stoic syllogisms. This paper argues that the customary translation of anapodeiktos by ‘indemonstrable’ is accurate, and it explains why this is so. At the heart of the explanation is an argument that, contrary to what is commonly assumed, indemonstrability is rooted in the generic account of the Stoic epistemic notion of demonstration (apodeixis). Some minor insights into Stoic logic ensue.

  • Allen, J. 2008. Inference from Signs: Ancient Debates about the Nature of Evidence. Oxford.

  • Annas, J. and Barnes, J. 2000. Sextus Empiricus: Outlines of Scepticism. Cambridge.

  • Barnes, J. 1980. Proof Destroyed. In: M. Schofield, M. Burnyeat and J. Barnes (eds.), Doubt and Dogmatism: Studies in Hellenistic Epistemology (Oxford), pp. 161-181.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Barnes, J. 1985. Theophrastus and Hypothetical Syllogistic. In: J. Wiesner (ed.), Aristoteles—Werk Und Wirkung. Vol. 1: Aristoteles Und Seine Schule (Berlin), pp. 557-576.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Barnes, J. 1994. Aristotle: Posterior Analytics. 2nd edn. Oxford.

  • Barnes, J. 2003. Proofs and Syllogisms in Galen. In: Galien et la Philosophie (Geneva), pp. 1-24.

  • Barnes, J. 2007. Truth, etc. Oxford.

  • Barnes, J. 2012. Theophrastus and Stoic Logic. In: Logical Matters (Oxford), pp. 413-432. [Revised reprint of Barnes 1985.]

  • Barnes, J., Bobzien, S., Flannery, K. and Ierodiakonou K. (trs.) 1991. Alexander of Aphrodisias: On Aristotle Prior Analytics 1.1-7. London.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Belli, M. 2014. Boethius, Disciple of Aristotle and Master of Theological Method. In: T. Böhm, T. Jürgasch and A. Kirchner (eds.), Boethius as a Paradigm of Late Ancient Thought (Berlin), pp. 53-82.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Bernays, P. 1926. Axiomatische Untersuchungen des Aussagen-Kalküls der Principia Mathematica. Mathematische Zeitschrift 25: pp. 305-320.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Bobzien, S. 1996. Stoic Syllogistic. Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 14: pp. 133-192.

  • Bobzien, S. 2019. Stoic Sequent Logic and Proof Theory. History and Philosophy of Logic 40: pp. 234-265.

  • Bronowski, A. 2019. The Stoics on Lekta. Oxford.

  • Brunschwig, J. 1995. Sur un titre d’ouvrage de Chrysippe: ‘Que les anciens ont admis la dialectique aux cotés de la démonstration’. In: Études sur les philosophies hellénistiques (Paris), pp. 233-250.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Buhle, J. G. 1801. Sextus Empirikus oder der Skepticismus der Griechen. Lemgo.

  • Bury, R. G. 1990. Sextus Empiricus: Outlines of Pyrrhonism. Buffalo, NY.

  • Fetherstone, T. et al. 1696. Diogenes Laertius. The Lives, Opinions, and Remarkable Sayings of the Most Famous Ancient Philosophers. Vol. 2. London.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Frede, M. 1974. Die stoische Logik. Göttingen.

  • Gentzen, G. 1934. Untersuchungen über das logische Schließen. I. Mathematische Zeitschrift 39: pp. 176-210. [English translation by M. E. Szabo: Investigations into Logical Deduction I. American Philosophical Quarterly 1 (1964), pp. 288-306. Also in M. E. Szabo, The Collected Works of Gerhard Gentzen. Amsterdam, 1969.]

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Hankinson, R. J. 2009. Galen on the Limitations of Knowledge. In: C. Gill, T. Whitmarsh and J. Wilkins (eds.), Galen and the World of Knowledge (Cambridge), pp. 206-242.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Hervet, G., tr. 1569. Sexti Empirici viri longe doctissimi adversus mathematicos, hoc est, adversus eos quo profitentur disciplinas, Opus eruditissimum Paris.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Hitchcock, D. 2005. The Peculiarities of Stoic Propositional Logic. In: J. Woods, K. A. Peacock and A. D. Irvine (eds.), Mistakes of Reason: Essays in Honour of John Woods (Toronto), pp. 224-242.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Huart, C., tr. 1725. Sextus Empiricus. Les Hipotiposes ou Institutions Pirroniennes en trois livres. Amsterdam (?).

  • Ierodiakonou, K. 2006. Stoic Logic. In: M. L. Gill and P. Pellegrin (eds.), A Companion to Ancient Philosophy (Oxford), pp. 505-529.

  • Kneale, W. and Kneale, M. 1962. The Development of Logic. Oxford.

  • Łukasiewicz, J. 1935. Zur Geschichte der Aussagenlogik. Erkenntnis 5: 111-131. [Translated by the author from his ‘Z historii logiki zdań’, Przegląd Filozoficzny 27 (1934), pp. 417-37. English translation as ‘On the History of the Logic of Propositions’ by S. McCall in Polish Logic 1920-1939 (Oxford, 1967), pp. 66-87.]

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Marrone, L., ed. 1997. Le Questioni Logiche di Crisippo (PHerc 307). Cronache Ercolanesi 27: pp. 83-100. [Edition of Chrysippus, Logical Investigations (λογικὰ ζητήµατα).]

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Mates, B. 1961. Stoic Logic. 2nd edn. Berkeley / Los Angeles.

  • Meiser, K., ed. 1880. Anicii Manlii Severini Boetii Commentarii In Librum Aristotelis Peri Hermenias. Leipzig.

  • Mueller, I. 1978. An Introduction to Stoic Logic. In: J. M. Rist, (ed.). The Stoics (Berkeley / Los Angeles), pp. 1-26.

  • Mueller, I. 1979. The Completeness of Stoic Propositional Logic. Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic 20: pp. 201-215.

  • Ramsey, E. 2017. A Commentary on the Peri Hermeneias Ascribed to Apuleius of Madaura. Phd. Thesis, Royal Holloway, University of London.

  • Stanley, T. 1701. History of Philosophy: Containing the Lives, Opinions, Actions and Discourses of the Philosophers of every Sect. 3rd edn. Part XII, London.

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Stephanus, H. [i.e. Henri Estienne]. tr. 1562. Sexti Empirici Pyrrhoniarum Hypotyposeon libri III. Geneva.

  • Thomsen Thörnqvist, C. 2008. Anicii Manlii Severini Boethii de Syllogismo Categorico. Gothenburg.

  • Traversari, A. 1455. Laertii Diogenis vitae atque sententiae eorum qui in philosophia claruerunt liber decimus et ultimus faeliciter explicit. Florence. Manuscript S. Marco 323 in the Biblioteca Medicea Laurenziana (digital copy online via: http://mss.bmlonline.it/).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Yonge, C. D., tr. 1853. Diogenes Laertius: The Lives and Opinions of Eminent Philosophers. London.

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 157 157 18
Full Text Views 27 27 5
PDF Downloads 27 27 3