Transition and Authority

Transwomen and Religious Leadership in the Netherlands

In: Religion and Gender

Abstract

The article presents two case studies of two women who were confronted with a loss of religious authority as they were asked to resign from their lay leading positions after their coming-out as transwomen in the Roman Catholic Church and the Protestant Church in the Netherlands. By focusing on these stories, this article provides further insight into queer lives in Europe starting from the intersections of gender, sexuality and religion. The cases show how the position of transwomen is negotiated by both religious structures as well as by transwomen themselves. The analysis focuses particularly on the interactions between the women and their community and church authorities and examines the use of gender/sexuality terminology, the role of the body, and the individualization of faith. This article brings together insights from religious studies, gender, trans* and queer studies, which allows for a multi-layered understanding of trans* and religion in a European context.

  • Abu-Lughod Lila. 1991. ‘Writing Against Culture’ in Fox RG (ed.) Recapturing Anthropology: Working in the Present: Seminar Papers Santa Fe: School of American Research Press pp. 137–161.

  • Asad Talal. 2003. Formations of the Secular. Christianity Islam Modernity Stanford: Stanford University Press.

  • Avishai Orit Lynne Gerber and Jennifer Randles. 2012. ‘The Feminist Ethnographer’s Dilemma: Reconciling Progressive Research Agendas with Fieldwork Realities’ Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 20:10 1–33. DOI: 10.1177/0891241612458955

  • Balkenhol Marcus Paul Mepschen and Jan Willem Duyvendak. 2016. ‘The Nativist Triangle: Sexuality Race and Religion in Discourses on “Dutchness” ’ in Duyvendak JW et al. (eds.) The Culturalization of Citizenship: Autochthony and Belonging in a Globalizing World Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan pp. 97–112.

  • Bernts Ton and Joantine Berghuijs. 2015. God in Nederland Utrecht: Ten Have.

  • Braidotti Rosi. 2008. ‘In Spite of the Times: the Post-Secular Turn in Feminism’ Theory Culture and Society 25:6 1–24. DOI: 10.1177/0263276408095542

  • Buijs Laurens Gert Hekma and Jan Willem Duyvendak. 2011. ‘ “As Long as They Keep Away from me”: The Paradox of Antigay Violence in a Gay-friendly Country’ Sexualities 14:6 632–652. DOI: 10.1177/1363460711422304

  • Butler Judith. 2008. ‘Sexual Politics Torture and Secular Time’ The British Journal of Sociology 59:1 1–23. DOI 10.1111/j.1468–4446.2007.00176.x

  • Casanova Jose. 2009. Religion Politics and Gender Equality: Public Religions Revisited New York: United Nations Research Institute for Social Development.

  • Catechism of the Catholic Church. 1993. Article 2297 accessed 29 November 2018 http://www.vatican.va/archive/ccc_css/archive/catechism/p3s2c2a5.htm

  • COC Nederland. 2013. ‘Senaat stemt voor transgenderwet’ 18 December accessed 29 November 2018 https://www.coc.nl/politiek-2/senaat-stemt-voor-transgenderwet

  • Cornwall Susannah. 2011. Controversies in Queer Theology London: SCM Press.

  • De Stentor Dronten. 2015. ‘Rhianna legt ontslagbrief voor aan Bureau Gelijke Behandeling’ December 9 accessed 29 November 2018 www.destentor.nl/regio/dronten/rhianna-legt-ontslagbrief-voor-aan-bureau-gelijke-behandeling-1.5524875

  • De Valk Eva. 2015. ‘Eerste Kamer stemt in met roze akkoord’ NRC Handelsblad 10 March accessed 29 November 2018 https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2015/03/10/eerste-kamer-stemt-in-met-roze-akkoord-coc-historische-dag-a1417983

  • Derks Marco. 2018. ‘Sexual and Religious Regimes of the Self in Dutch Discourses about Homosexuality: A Queer Theological Analysis and Alternative’ International Journal of Public Theology 12 353–378. DOI:10.1163/15697320-12341547

  • Derks Marco. 2017. ‘Conscientious Objectors and the Marrying Kind: Rights and Rites in Dutch Public Discourse on Marriage Registrars with Conscientious Objections Against Conducting Same-Sex Weddings’ Theology and Sexuality 23:3 209–228 DOI: 10.1080/13558358.2017.1351124

  • Dommerholt Anton. 2015. ‘Ophef in RKK Dronten rond transgender’ Reformatorisch Dagblad 15 July accessed 29 November 2018. https://www.rd.nl/kerk-religie/ophef-in-rkk-dronten-over-ontslag-transgender-1.483590

  • Dzmura Noach. 2010. Balancing on the Mechitza: Transgender in Jewish Community Berkely: North Atlantic Books.

  • Ganzevoort Ruard Erik Olsman and Mark van der Laan. 2010. Adam en Evert: de spanning tussen kerk en homoseksualiteit Kampen: Ten Have.

  • Ganzevoort Ruard. 2011. ‘Narrative Approaches’ in Miller-McLemore B. (ed.) Wiley-Blackwell Companion to Practical Theology Chistester: Wiley-Blackwell 214–223.

  • Garvin Patrick. 2019. ‘What’s the Asterisk in “Trans*” Mean and Why Do Some Find It Offensive?’ The LGBTQ+ Experiment 18 February accessed 11 June 2019 https://lgbtqexperiment.com/2019/02/18/is-there-a-difference-between-trans-and-trans-is-trans-offensive/

  • Geuze Susanne. 2015. ‘ “Desnoods gaan we naar de paus in Rome” ’ De Volkskrant 15 July accessed 29 July 2018 www.volkskrant.nl/binnenland/-desnoods-gaan-we-naar-de-paus-in-rome~a4101000/

  • Göle Nilufer. 2010. ‘The Civilizational Spatial and Sexual Powers of the Secular’ in M. Warner et al. (eds.) Varieties of Secularism in a Secular Age Cambridge: Harvard University Press 243–264.

  • Green Eli R. 2006. ‘Debating Trans Inclusion in the Feminist Movement: A Trans-Positive Analysis’ Journal of Lesbian Studies 10:1/2 231–248. DOI: 10.1300/J155v10n01_12

  • Hekma Gert and Jan Willem Duyvendak. 2011. ‘Queer Netherlands: A Puzzling Example’ Sexualities 14:6 625–631. DOI 10.1177/1363460711422303

  • Hekma Gert. 2004. Homoseksualiteit in Nederland van 1730 tot de moderne tijd Amsterdam: Meulenhoff.

  • Isherwood Lisa and Marcella Althaus-Reid. 2009. Trans/Formations London: Hymns Ancient & Modern Ltd.

  • Jakobsen Janet and Ann Pellegrini. 2004. Love the Sin: Sexual Regulation and the Limits of Religious Tolerance Boston: Beacon Press.

  • Kleinjan Gert-Jan. 2015a. ‘Groeiende steun voor roomse transgender die ontslag wacht’ Trouw 10 July accessed 29 November 2018 https://ww.trouw.nl/tr/nl/5009/Archief/article/detail/4098234/2015/07/10/Groeiende-steun-voor-roomse-transgender-die-ontslag-wacht.dhtml

  • Kleinjan Gert-Jan. 2015b. ‘Van hogerhand vernederd’ Trouw 1 July accessed 29 November 2018 www.trouw.nl/tr/nl/5009/Archief/article/detail/4091959/2015/07/01/Van-hogerhand-vernederd.dhtml

  • Kobessen Guido. 2015. ‘Bijzonder apostel van Onze Lieve-Heer’ De Stentor Dronten 24 December page 12.

  • Lechner Frank J. 1996. ‘Secularization in the Netherlands?’ Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 35:3 252–264. DOI 10.2307/1386556

  • LKP and WKHP. 2015. ‘WKHP en LKP geschokt over ontslag transgender penningmeester’ July 8 2015 accessed 29 November 2018 https://www.homopastor.nl/assets/files/2015-07-08%20persbericht%20WKHP-LKP%20-%20ontslag%20trans%20penningmeester%20Rhianna%20Gralike.pdf

  • Loughlin Gerard et al. 2007. Queer Theology: Rethinking the Western Body Malden: Wiley-Blackwell.

  • Mahmood Saba. 2005. Politics of Piety: The Islamic Revival and the Feminist Subject Princeton: Princeton University Press.

  • Omroep Flevoland. 2015. ‘Zaak transgender Gralike wordt onderzocht’ 9 December accessed 29 November 2018 https://www.omroepflevoland.nl/nieuws/130500/dronten-zaak-transgender-gralike-wordt-onderzocht

  • Protestantse Kerk Nederland. 2018. ‘Kerkelijk werker: ambt en bediening’ accessed 29 November 2018 https://www.protestantsekerk.nl/actief-in-de-kerk/werken/kerkelijk-werker/ambt-en-bediening

  • Schmeets Hans and Carly van Mensvoort. 2015. Religieuze betrokkenheid van bevolkingsgroepen Den Haag: Centraal Bureau voor de Statistiek.

  • Schrijver Annemiek. 2015. ‘De Ochtendkus: Rhianna Gralike’ TV programme by NCRV aired 18 November 2015 on NPO 1 accessed 29 November 2018 https://www.npo.nl/transgender-niet-welkom-in-kerk/29-10-2015/WO_NCRV_2406932

  • Schrijvers Lieke L. and Jelle Wiering. 2018. ‘Religious/Secular Discourses and Practices of Good Sex’ Culture and Religion 19:2 139–159. DOI: 10.1080/14755610.2018.1444655

  • Schrijvers Lieke L. 2015. ‘ “I Can Now Thank God when I Come”: Sex Faith and the Body in the Lives of Non-Heterosexual Dutch Protestant Women’ Tijdschrift voor Genderstudies 18:1 35–53. DOI: 10.5117/TVGN2015.1.SCHR

  • Scott Joan W. 2018. Sex and Secularism Princeton: Princeton University Press.

  • Steinmetz Katy. 2018. ‘The Oxford English Dictionary Added ‘Trans*.’ Here’s What the Label Means’ Time 3 April accessed 11 June 2019 https://time.com/5211799/what-does-trans-asterisk-star-mean-dictionary/

  • Tanis Justin E. 2003. Trans-Gendered: Theology Ministry and Communities of Faith Cleveland: Pilgrim Press.

  • Trouw. 2015. ‘Transgender uit bestuur van parochie in Dronten’ 4 December accessed 29 November 2018 https://ww.trouw.nl/tr/nl/5009/Archief/article/detail/4201355/2015/12/04/Transgender-uit-bestuur-van-parochie-in-Dronten.dhtml

  • Trouw. 2012. ‘Conservatieve Eijk ontvangt kardinaalshoed in Rome’ 18 February accessed 29 November 2018 https:/www.trouw.nl/tr/nl/5091/Religie/article/detail/3188196/2012/02/18/Conservatieve-Eijk-ontvangt-kardinaalshoed-in-Rome.dhtml

  • Tubantia. 2015. ‘Kardinaal Eijk wil af van transseksuele boekhouder’ 29 June accessed 29 November 2018 www.tubantia.nl/algemeen/binnenland/kardinaal-eijk-wil-af-van-transseksuele-boekhouder-1.5040951

  • Van den Berg Mariecke et al. 2014. ‘Religion Homosexuality and Contested Social Orders in the Netherlands the Western Balkans and Sweden’ in Ganiel G. et al. (eds.) Religion and the Social Order Boston: Brill 116–134.

  • Van den Berg Mariecke and Mir Marinus. 2017. ‘Trans Scripts—The Representation of Transgender People in the Media in the Netherlands (1991–2016)’ Tijdschrift voor Genderstudies 20:4 379–397. DOI: 10.5117/TVGN2017.4.BERG

  • Wilcox Melissa. 2009. Queer Women and Religious Individualism Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

  • Zorgdrager Heleen et al. (eds.) 2019. Wondermooi zoals U mij gemaakt hebt: Handreiking voor gelovige transgender personen en werkers in de kerk Utrecht: KokBoekencentrum.

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 120 120 19
Full Text Views 8 8 2
PDF Downloads 3 3 1