Restricted Access
Get Access to Full Text
Rent on DeepDyve

Have an Access Token?

Enter your access token to activate and access content online.

Please login and go to your personal user account to enter your access token.


Have Institutional Access?

Access content through your institution. Any other coaching guidance?


In Unbelievable Errors, Bart Streumer offers resourceful arguments against each of non-reductive realism, reductive realism, and non-cognitivism, in order to motivate his version of the normative error theory, according to which normative predicates ascribe properties that do not exist. In this contribution, I argue that none of the steps of this master argument succeed, and that Streumer’s arguments leave puzzles about what it means to ascribe a property at all.



Blackburn S. 1973. “Moral Realism.” In Casey J. (ed.) Morality and Moral Reasoning101124. London: Methuen.

Brown C. 2011. “A New and Improved Supervenience Argument for Ethical DescriptivismOxford Studies in Metaethics 6: 205218.

Dreier J. 1996. “Expressivist Embeddings and Minimalist TruthPhilosophical Studies 83: 2951.

Dunaway B. 2015. “Supervenience Arguments and Normative NonnaturalismPhilosophy and Phenomenological Research 91: 627655.

Finlay S. 2008. “The Error in the Error TheoryAustralasian Journal of Philosophy 86: 347369.

Gibbard A. 2003. Thinking How to Live. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Horgan T. and Timmons M. 1991. “New Wave Moral Realism Meets Moral Twin EarthJournal of Philosophical Research 16: 447465.

Horgan T. and Timmons M. 1992. “Troubles for New Wave Moral Semantics: The Open Question Argument RevivedPhilosophical Papers 21/3: 153175.

Horgan T. and Timmons M. 1996a. “Troubles for Michael Smith’s Metaethical RationalismPhilosophical Papers 25/3: 203231.

Horgan T. and Timmons M. 1996b. “From Moral Realism to Moral Relativism in One Easy StepCritica: Revista Hisponoamericana de Filosofía 28: 339.

Horgan T. and Timmons M. 2000. “Copping Out on Moral Twin EarthSynthese 124: 139152.

Horgan T. and Timmons M. 2009. “Analytical Functionalism Meets Moral Twin Earth.” In Ravenscroft I. (ed.) Mind Ethics and Conditionals: Themes from the Philosophy of Frank Jackson. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Horgan T. and Timmons M. 2004. “Cognitivist Expressivism.” In Horgan T. and Timmons M. (eds.) Metaethics After Moore255298. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Jackson F. 1998. From Metaphysics to Ethics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Joyce R. 2001. The Myth of Morality. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kim J. 1984. “Concepts of SuperveniencePhilosophy and Phenomenological Research 45: 153176.

Oddie G. 2005. Value Reality and Desire. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Olson J. 2014. Moral Error Theory: History Critique Defense. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Perl C. and Schroeder M. Forthcoming. “Attributing Error Without Taking a Stand” Philosophical Studies.

Schmitt J. and Schroeder M. 2011. “Supervenience Arguments Under Relaxed AssumptionsPhilosophical Studies 155: 133160.

Schroeder M. 2005. “Realism and Reduction: The Quest for Robustness” Philosophers’ Imprint 5/1.

Schroeder M. 2007. Slaves of the Passions. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Schroeder M. 2008. Being For: Evaluating the Semantic Program of Expressivism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Schroeder M. 2008. “How Expressivists Can and Should Solve Their Problem with NegationNoûs 42/4: 573599.

Schroeder M. 2013. “Two Roles for Propositions: Cause for Divorce?” Noûs 47/3: 409430.

Schroeder M. 2014. “The Price of Supervenience.” In Schroeder M. Explaining the Reasons We Share volume 1 of Explanation and Expression in Ethics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Schroeder M. 2015. Expressing Our Attitudes volume 2 of Explanation and Expression in Ethics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Schroeder M. ms. “A Common Subject for Ethics.”

Shope R. 1978. “The Conditional Fallacy in Contemporary PhilosophyThe Journal of Philosophy 75/8: 379413.

Streumer B. 2017. Unbelievable Errors. Oxford: Oxford University Press.


Content Metrics

Content Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 67 67 38
Full Text Views 46 46 27
PDF Downloads 16 16 7
EPUB Downloads 0 0 0