Jasper and Poulsen (1995) have long argued that moral shocks are critical for recruitment in the nonhuman animal rights movement. Building on this, Decoux (2009) argues that the abolitionist faction of the nonhuman animal rights movement fails to recruit members because it does not effectively utilize descriptions of suffering. However, the effectiveness of moral shocks and subsequent emotional reactions has been questioned. This article reviews the literature surrounding the use of moral shocks in social movements. Based on this review, it is suggested that the exploitation of emotional reactions to depictions of suffering can sometimes prove beneficial to recruitment, but successful use is contextually rooted in preexisting frameworks, ideology, and identity. It is concluded that a reliance on images and narratives might be misconstrued in a society dominated by nonhuman animal welfare ideology.
GrovesJ. M.GoodwinJ.JasperJ. M.PollettaF.Animal rights and the politics of emotion: Folk constructions of emotion in the animal rights movementPassionate politics: Emotions and social movements2001ChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press212232
Kilstein J. & Kilkenny A. (Hosts)Animal rights icon Gary Francione, Citizen Radio invades Democracy NowCitizen Radio2011March29[Show 259] [Podcast]. Retrieved August 3 2011 from: http://wearecitizenradio.com/2011/03/29/20110329-animal-rights-icon-gary-francione-citizen-radio-invades-democracy-now/.
NepstadS.SmithC.GoodwinJ.JasperJ.PollettaF.The social structure of moral outrage in recruitment to the U.S. Central America peace movementPassionate politics: Emotions and social movements2001158174ChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press
YatesR.Animal welfarism: The strength and resilience of the orthodoxOn human-nonhuman relations: A sociological exploration of speciesism2007Retrieved November 18 2010 from: http://human-nonhuman.blogspot.com/2007/03/animal-welfarism-strength-and.html.
YatesR.The strength of dominant paradigms: Can animal advocates liberate themselves from animal welfarism?On human-nonhuman relations: A sociological exploration of speciesism2009Retrieved November 18 2010 from: http://human-nonhuman.blogspot.com/2009/03/strength-of-dominant-paradigms-can.html.