Formal Axiology and Its Critics


Editor: Rem B. Edwards
Formal Axiology and Its Critics consists of two parts, both of which present criticisms of the formal theory of values developed by Robert S. Hartman, replies to these criticisms, plus a short introduction to formal axiology.
Part I consists of articles published or made public during the lifetime of Hartman to which he personally replied. It contains previously published replies to Hector Neri Castañeda, William Eckhardt, and Robert S. Brumbaugh, and previously unpublished replies to Charles Hartshorne, Rem B. Edwards, Robert E. Carter, G.R. Grice, Nicholas Rescher, Robert W. Mueller, Gordon Welty, Pete Gunter, and George K. Plochmann in an unfinished but now completed article on which Hartman was working at the time of his death in 1973.
Part II consists of articles presented at recent annual meetings of the R.S. Hartman Institute for Formal and Applied Axiology that continue to criticize and further develop Hartman's formal axiology. An article by Rem B. Edwards raises serious unanswered questions about formal axiology and ethics. Another by Frank G. Forrest shows how the formal value calculus based on set theory might answer these questions, and an article by Mark A. Moore points out weaknesses in the Hartman/Forrest value calculus and develops an alternative calculus based upon the mathematics of quantum mechanics.
While recognizing that unsolved problems remain, the book intends to make the theoretical foundations and future promise of formal axiology much more secure.

Table of contents

Rem B. EDWARDS: Editorial Foreword. Acknowledgments. Chapter ONE: Rem B. EDWARDS: Introduction. Endnotes. PART ONE: EARLIEST CRITICS. Chapter TWO: Robert S. HARTMAN: Axiology as a Science: Reply to Hector Neri Castañeda, 1961. Chapter THREE: Rem B. EDWARDS: Some Spurious Proofs for the Pure Ego. Chapter FOUR: Robert S. HARTMAN: Formal Axiology and Its Critics. PART TWO: CONTEMPORARY CRITICS. Chapter FIVE: Rem B. EDWARDS: Ten Unanswered Questions. Chapter SIX: Frank G. FORREST: A Reply to Ten Unanswered Questions. Chapter SEVEN: Mark A. MOORE: A Quantum Wave Model of Value Theory. About the Contributors. Index.